>>55658
I'm glad someone likes it. I think that it would be a good basis for South Park to transition to a format focusing on more characters, sort of answering the show's Member Berries joke. A lot of it could be recycled scrapped material from SOT and TFBW, particularly for a Goth Kids 4, which could make jokes about how Goth, Emo, and Vamp have become irrelevant and explain it as the consequence of some sort of long shadow war that they need Butters to help fight as Henrietta has been kidnapped by the Vamps to turn her into some sort of ultimate being, her having previously been an Emo, and so Count Ravyncrowe, who usurped Mike and now leads the Vamps with the goal of taking the war into the open, can have a girlfriend. In this episode particularly, there'd be clarification over Michael's ancestry as Cartman, through Butters, forces him to confront how he's a "half breed," being half-White and half-Chinese, and how that could turn the tide. After trying to learn martial arts from Tuong Lu Kim, it's revealed that he has no aptitude for it and is instead adept at yaoi, an ability that could let him halve Vamp numbers by converting the girls in it to whatever the Asian girls from the yaoi episode are.
However, he can only gain this power if he undergoes a makeover by these same yaoi girls, compromising his Goth orthodoxy. I don't know how things would go from there, but the episode would end with the ultimate being being made out of Firkle in a Dune reference after Butters usurps Count Ravyncrowe and impresses Henrietta, hinting at a future pairing of the two and character growth for Butters. Firkle would declare that Goth, Vamp, and Emo are actually all the same thing, not because of a lack of inherent differences as stated in Goth Kids 3, but because nobody knows what the terms mean anymore as culture has passed them by.
He'd christen the new, unified clique, and the episode's last scene would be the Goth Kids sitting behind the school again. One of them would ask what happens now, and if they can still call themselves Goths. The twist to end the episode would be Firkle answering, "Duh, of course we can. What are we, conformists?" or something along that line. The episode as a whole would be an inversion of Cartman's Atheist two-parter.
>>55693
I agree. I've always wondered by Matt and Trey never attempted to move them into 5th Grade. Maybe it's due to how entrenched South Park became. Unlike cartoons from the 2010s, European cartoons, and anime, it's a major brand risk to change a character's appearance. Every piece of South Park merchandise would no longer reflect how they look on-screen, and reusing character assets in video games would be impossible. This isn't to mention animation costs. I think this may be why episodes revolving around other characters were phased out too.