>>1087638
>Some people eat shit and fuck their cousins. You know, like your parents. That doesn't mean that we don't have instincts against it.
And that doesn’t mean we do have instincts against DK’s redesign. You’re aware what a bad argument you’re making, right?
<What? You don’t feel the instinctual obligation to give me a million dollars? Some people people eat shit and fuck their cousins, despite our instincts telling us not to do such things. Therefore you are just a mentally ill commie for not giving me a million bucks.
Eating shit and fucking cousins are both tied to sexual disorders. No one has found and ties between liking DK’s redesign and any disorders, to my knowledge.
>There is no objective scientific reason why St. Peter's is more beautiful than the AT&T Building in New York, but it is.
Firstly, if you’re saying something actually is more beautiful than something else, regardless of personal opinion, then you are saying it is objectively more beautiful.
Objective means personal representing facts not influenced by feelings or opinions. So even if you can’t explain why or how something exists, if you’re claiming that it actually exists then you’re claiming it objectively exists.
Second of all, I would argue there are various traits all humans, baring mental disorders, find beautiful. Art snobs who pay millions for blank canvas do not actually find the blank canvas itself appealing to look at, they find the “theme” behind it appealing. But, as a most basic example, every human on earth would find a canvas with something on it more interesting to look at for its own sake than a blank canvas. So there’s definitely a degree to which beautiful is objective, but the exact degree is fuzzy.
The example I provided is just a simple, unambiguous example.
> It's because your argument is just arguing that if you can't come up why an objective reason why something is better, then it can't be better
You didn’t come up with any reason why, you were just saying it is. At least the other guys gave some rational for their opinions.