I was recently gifted Sonic Origins Plus for Switch. People complained about this game a lot, but I haven't noticed many problems yet, except that the "Plus" content is a download, making the physical version bullshit, but retards on this site use Steam, so they wouldn't care.
Another famous thing about Origins is that it changed some of the music in Sonic 3, the stuff that everyone is pretty sure was by Michael Jackson. While I do love the originals, the ones used in Origins didn't bother me as much as I thought they would. As fans have figured out, these ones are actually the originals, and were replaced once Jackson came on board, so these fit the game well, arguably even better. But I'll always have a hard time getting over the loss of Ice Cap Zone's awesome music.
Or I could just play the old versions, or the many hacks and mods people have made. But these are simple, and I like having them on a portable system like the Switch. They have widescreen and all that. The ability to play as Tails, Knuckles, and Amy (and Knuckles/Amy & Tails) is nice. The ability for them all to become Super in any game is nice (though you need cheats to do it in games where it couldn't originally be done).
The "Story Mode" where you play all the games in a row, with new FMV cutscenes connecting them, is nice. However, I wish that in Plus, there was an option to play Story Mode with all the Game Gear games added in. They don't need to make new cutscenes, just let me play all the games in a row, pretending they're one giant game. I know I can just pick them from the menu. That's not the point. That's not what I want. Story Mode is pretty fun, so if they added new games, add them to Story Mode.
Oh yeah, it also bugs me that they left out Spinball, 3D Blast, and Chaotix. Everyone talks about how they should have had all the Master System games, since fans seem to prefer those versions over their Game Gear equivalents (which are often ports), but I'm missing the rest of the Genesis games more. They have Spinball for Game Gear, which is practically unplayable, but couldn't include the real version of Spinball? That's a much bigger travesty than not having the Master System version of Sonic 1 and 2. I know modern perceptions of Genesis Spinball aren't great anymore, but that was a high selling game. Growing up, that was a legitimate Sonic game to me. It's referenced in Origins, with its island appearing on the menu, along with 3D Blast's. Just include it.
Also, 3D Blast is actually a very good game, and I'm tired of pretending it's not. And original director Jon Burton actually made a Director's Cut a few years ago. If he can do it, Sega could just copy his work exactly and could have included it here. They could even make it a selling point, a new and improved version. Nerds will know it already existed, but now it would be official. And of course they should make it widescreen too, but that fantasy might be a step too far. I understand this is Sega I'm talking about. But still, even if they only included Genesis 3D Blast in its most basic form, I would have appreciated it. That's a good game.
And I know Chaotix is also a game that gets very mixed reception. Personally, I think it's only really fun if you have a friend who is also a massive Sonic fan, so that you can both try to learn and get used to the game together. Adjusting to the ridiculous rubber-band mechanic is certainly a challenge. But come on. They included Spinball for Game Gear. Chaotix is better than that, and the closest you get to a "canon" sequel to Sonic & Knuckles, at least until Sonic Adventure. It's basically the same team that made Sonic CD, and it shows. It should have been included for sure.
All that said, I've still beaten all the four/five main games included here, with all characters. Of course, I've done that before, but Amy is new and kind of neat, even if she is basically just Sonic 3 Sonic without the elemental shields.
Next I'm going to do one more run as Sonic, through all the games, including the Game Gear games. I'll do the real Story Mode, in the proper order. Well I guess it won't be fully as Sonic, since the two Tails games are included. And also it will bug me that Genesis Spinball, Chaotix, and 3D Blast aren't here, so maybe I'll just play those outside this compilation. Except Spinball is so absurdly hard, and Chaotix actually does suck without a second player who is in the same mood for such a ridiculous game. But come on, I'm not gonna play Sonic Blast and not Sonic 3D Blast.
That said, I will play Sonic Blast twice, because after beating every game in a row in the canon route (including Knuckles in Sonic 3 & Knuckles, but not in the other games), I'll then go and do the Game Gear games as the secondary characters. At least I'll do Tails in Sonic & Tails 1 and 2, and Knuckles in Sonic Blast. I don't think I'll be beating Sonic Drift 1 and 2 with every character. But maybe that will be the very last thing I do. Those games aren't so bad once you get used to them. Sonic Drift 2 actually becomes pretty charming.
>tl;dr: Sonic Origins Plus should have had everything on the actual physical cart, obviously, and it should have included Genesis Spinball, Chaotix, and 3D Blast (ideally upgraded like the DX version, which isn't official but should be, and is by the actual director). And yes, it should have included the Master System versions as well. But I still liked it enough to beat the hell out of every bit of content it has. Well almost. Still gotta do the Game Gear games. But I like most of them so that's fine. Maybe not Game Gear Spinball though. That game is practically unplayable. Sonic Blast also sucks, but I'll still beat it twice.
Now to wait for Sonic's 40th Anniversary compilation, when they can actually include all the games. But you know what I really want? Forget the Master System versions. Why doesn't somebody, even a fan, just make faithful recreations of the 8-bit games, but on Genesis. Every damn Sonic game has a million hacks. There are so many Sonic fan games, including ones that claim to be remakes of the 8-bit games, but really what they are are new games with some elements inspired by the 8-bit games. I want the actual 8-bit games, with the same level layouts, but on Genesis, with Genesis graphics. Like Sonic 1 8-bit re-uses several of the same level themes from the Genesis game, but with new layouts. Give me those layouts but on Genesis. And then I'm sure the autists that make Sonic hacks wouldn't have any problem recreating the original level themes like Bridge Zone or Sky Base Zone. Bridge Zone isn't even really an original theme either. What Sega needs to do is hire some nerds to just make these games faithfully, then include them in a massive Story Mode for the next Sonic compilation. And include the remaining Genesis/32X games like I've been complaining about.
Now, what a lot of people don't know is that Sonic 1 for Master System actually has surprisingly different level layouts than Sonic 1 for Game Gear. So that makes it tricky, because I know they would never remake both. I guess the Master System version was the original, so okay, make that the base. But I personally had the Game Gear version as a kid, because nobody even heard of Master System back then, so I would miss the Game Gear version. But still, just make these games for Genesis, Sega.
Also, include Sonic R. I know it's a Saturn game, but come on. Just include all the games that came out before Sonic Adventure. I'll cut some slack and allow Sonic Jam to be left out, since Sonic World isn't a real game, and the Game.com version of Sonic Jam is one of the worst games ever made. But Sonic R is good, and like I said about 3D Blast, I'm tired of pretending its not. Traveller's Tales made some good games back in the '90s.