>>607794
28% CRIT Rate is absolutely better than 18% combat ATK.
>and 27%
Doesn't happen, never consider three-stack woodpecker in your calculations. It might as well not exist.
You land way more important attacks into 9% than into 27%.
Also, yes, 28% CRIT Rate is better than 27% combat ATK as well.
Also, also, you should be running Hormone.
>also fire dmg barely does anything on her If you use Lighter, wich I do
With both Lighter and Astra (assuming her W-Engine, which you probably don't have), you're only getting 139% DMG increase, while Evelyn has a grand total of 30% on her own kit specifically for Chain and Ultimate.
10% Fire DMG on top of that is a 3.7% multiplicative damage increase, which is 2-3 sub-stats worth.
The real problem with IM on Evelyn is not that the set effect doesn't mog the shit out of all the alternatives - it does, as it's literally the highest value set in the game, arguably behind Yunkui now.
It's that you can't really have a proper set of discs while running it.
You have six discs that can roll three good sub-stats - CRIT Rate%, CRIT DMG%, ATK% - running IM with "perfect" discs means you'll have to land 4 out of those into CRIT DMG%, ATK%, flat PEN, which is simply less value than getting CRIT Rate% from them instead.