>>1943
>why the fuck would people who live in a forest have long, flowing robes with enormous sleeves all made of thin material?
Because they live in buildings in said forest, ala Rivendell? Not to mention all the times they’ve been depicted living in stone buildings.
>Can you imagine trying to not tear gaping holes in all that fine stitching and lace while just walking from tree to tree every day?
They would just walk across constructed bridges between trees, ala Lothlorien.
>They would have to be super careful, because replacing that stuff would be especially difficult without sewing machines
They have plenty of time to sew, being serially longevial
>Even if it were tough silk, can you imagine the stains? Silk stains like nothing else.
>And what the hell is with all the delicate filigree on every metal implement that they create?
Aesthetics.
>An elf would have to clean everything he uses with a toothbrush and polish every day.
Plenty of time.
>On top of that, have you ever heard of an elvish mine?
Yes.
>Where are they even getting all those rare alloys?
Aside from mining, they could also get it via trade.
>Elves should dress like people who live in forests actually dress--in very, very little, all of which is made of tough, simple leather and hides. If they have armour, it should be made of bamboo or bone to be light and to move easily.
These are “wood elves”. Specifically the kind from Warhammer fantasy and TES. They are not the only kind, but they are already a thing.
Your grievances over elf attire don’t make much sense.