>>1492
>Yeah, it might seem a bit crazy, but I liked the self-contained story of the first movie.
That self-contained story had practically nothing to do with Sonic, though. It was just a generic half-CGI kids' movie, and I wouldn't say a particularly good one. Without the connection to Sonic, why would I care? The little connection it does have only makes me mad, since it's so different from the source material that it all feels like wasted opportunity to make an actual adaptation.
>Overall, they deviated too much from the game's plot.
But you just said you liked Sonic 1, which doesn't just deviate from plot (Sonic is an alien), but from the characters, which I think is the bigger crime (Sonic is a lonely child). Sonic 2 obviously takes enormous detours, what with the sassy fat black woman's wedding, but even with the bits they do adapt, they
merge the Chaos Emeralds and the Master Emerald, Knuckles' people were genocided not by Chaos and their own hubris, but by Sonic's adopted mother, an owl, clearly because they only played the first game and saw vaguely owl-like figures in the background of Labyrinth Zone). Angel Island isn't a thing, and they couldn't even be bothered to have the underwater ruins be Lost World, Hydrocity, or Aquatic Ruin, as they're clearly Labyrinth Zone, again because they clearly only played the first game.
>The City Escape quote was shoehorned badly
Agreed. I do think it could have been delivered properly, but I don't think the actor even knew it was a quote.
>The writers forgot that Sonic is supposed to be cool and relaxed a vast majority of the time
This is my biggest problem with the whole series, but especially the first movie. Across all the other adaptations, Sonic generally acts like Sonic. This is the only one where he is a vastly different character. I do think it gets slightly better in each sequel, and by the third one, when he does lose his cool a bit, I think it's justified well enough, and ties in with Shadow's themes, so I'm okay with it.
I think you're remembering everything correctly, I just think it's crazy to be mad about the movie with the fewest deviations from the source material, including the characters, and the fewest cringey modern kids' movie moments, but forgiving those transgressions in movies that had those problems in much higher quantities. Plus, I also don't give a single shit about the emotional arcs in Sonic 1 or 2, but at least Shadow's arc is actually retained in Sonic 3, and I do think that one is at least somewhat effective.